Fitbit Charge 5 vs Garmin Vivosmart 5 vs Fitbit Luxe Compared

If you find this post helpful, please share it. Thank you!

In today’s comparison, we’ll be looking at the differences between the Fitbit Charge 5 vs Garmin Vivosmart 5 vs Fitbit Luxe – which is the right choice for you? Well, hopefully, this comparison will help you decide on which of these is the right smartband for you.

One thing you should have in mind is that each of these three is a fantastic activity tracker that can keep you connected as well as help you reach more fitness goals. While the Charge 5 and Luxe are two of the best trackers from Fitbit, the Vivosmart 5 is currently the best and most popular tracker from Garmin. Each of these shares a lot in common including price and features, which of course is why we are comparing these three to help you decide which is worth your money.

The difference between the Charge 5 and Vivosmart 5 is that the former has a better build and a more colorful AMOLED display. And unlike Vivosmart 5, it also has inbuilt GPS and features Fitbit Pay, thanks to the built-in NFC. Moreover, the Charge 5 can monitor your skin temperature variation and features ECG which are not present in Vivosmart 5. On the other hand, Vivosmart 5 features incidental fall detection and LiveTrack which makes it a better option for outdoor workout lovers.

Meanwhile, Fitbit Luxe also has a durable stainless steel build and a colorful AMOLED display like the Charge 5, but it lacks inbuilt GPS, NFC, and ECG measurement.

Fitbit Charge 5 vs Garmin Vivosmart 5 vs Fitbit Luxe Full Specifications

Product Info
Fitbit Charge 5 full specifications

Fitbit Charge 5 Specifications, Features and Price

Garmin Vivosmart 5 - Full Smartwatch Specifications

Garmin Vivosmart 5 - Full Smartwatch Specifications

Fitbit Luxe Full Specifications, Features and Prices

Price $149.95 $149.99 $99.95
Device name Fitbit Charge 5 Garmin Vivosmart 5 Fitbit Luxe (Standard edition)
Device type Fitness smartband Fitness/Sport smartwatch Fitness smartband
Gender Unisex Unisex Unisex
Release date September, 2021 April 2022 June, 2021
Predecessor Fitbit Charge 4 Garmin Vivosmart 4
Versions Small & Large Standard edition & Special edition
Dimension 36.7 x 22.7 x 11.2 mm 19.5 x 10.7 x 217mm (small), 19.5 x 10.7 x 255 mm (large) 36.3 x 17.5 x 10 mm
Weight 28g 24.5g (small), 26.5g (large)
Shape Rectangular Rectangular Rectangular
Case material Aluminum Fiber-reinforced polymer Stainless steel
Strap material Silicone Silicone Silicone
Bezel material Aluminum Fiber-reinforced polymer Stainless steel
Strap size 140 – 180mm (small), 180 -220mm (big) 20 mm 140 – 180mm (small), 180 -220mm (big)
Interchangeable strap Yes Yes Yes
Screen protection Corning Gorilla Glass 3 Acrylic Corning Gorilla Glass
Water resistance Yes, 5ATM Yes, 5ATM Yes, 5ATM
Durability test
Swim-proof Yes, recommended Yes, recommended Yes, recommended
Color Black/Graphite Stainless Steel strap, Lunar White/Soft-Gold Stainless Steel strap, Steel Blue/Platinum Stainless Steel strap Black, White, Cool mint Graphite/black, Lunar/white, Platinum/orchid
Display size 1.04 inches 0.84 inch 0.76 inch
Display type 450nits, AMOLED Monochrome OLED AMOLED
Display resolution 0.86″ x 0.58″px 88 x 154 pixels 124 x 206 px
Pixel density 326 ppi 211.15 PPI 326 ppi
Always on Yes Yes No
Custom watch face Yes Yes Yes
Input type Touchscreen 1 Physical button, Touchscreen Touchscreen
Bluetooth Bluetooth v4.0 ANT+, Bluetooth Bluetooth v4.0
Bluetooth calling No No No
GPS Yes (connected GPS) (connected GPS), No
NFC Yes No No
Wi-Fi No No No
Memory card slot No No No
Technology None None None
SIM type None None None
SMS alert Yes Yes Yes
Calls alert Yes Yes Yes
Email alert Yes Yes Yes
Event reminder Yes Yes Yes
Third-party apps alert Yes Yes Yes
Reply to Notifications - Android only, Yes (preset replies) -
Audio No No No
Bluetooth music No No No
Loudspeaker No No No
Microphone No No No
Camera No No No
Radio No No No
Sensor(s) EDA Stress sensor, Vibration motor Red and infrared sensors, Vibration motor
Blood oxygen Yes Yes Yes
Blood Pressure No No -
Calories Yes Yes Yes
Distance Yes Yes Yes
ECG tracking Yes No No
Heart rate monitoring Yes Yes Yes
Sleep tracking Yes Yes Yes
Steps Yes Yes Yes
Floors climbed No No -
Stress Yes Yes Yes
Fall detection No Yes No
Menstrual cycle Yes Yes Yes
VO2 Max Yes Yes Yes
Swim-tracking Yes Yes Yes
Underwater heart rate tracking No No No
On-screen workout No No No
Sport modes 20 Yes 20+
Battery type non-removable Lithium-polymer non-removable Lithium-polymer
Battery capacity
Battery life Regular: 7 days+, Standby:10 days+ Mixed usage: Up to 7 days Regular: 5 days+
Charging type Charging dock Charging dock Charging dock
Charging time 2hrs 1-2 hours 1-2 hours
Solar charging No No No
Chipset N/A
Operating system Fitbit OS Proprietary OS Fitbit OS
Companion app Fitbit App Garmin Connect Fitbit App
Compatibility Android, iOS Android 7.0+, iOS 15.0+ Android OS 8.0+, iOS 13.3+
Payment system Fitbit Pay None None
Voice command No No No
Find my phone Yes Yes Yes
Box content Charger, Fitbit Charge 5, Manual, Straps Charger, Manual, Straps, Garmin Vivosmart 5 Charger, Fitbit Luxe, Manual, Straps (small & large)

Fitbit Charge 5 vs Garmin Vivosmart 5 vs Fitbit Luxe – The Differences

Without wasting your time, let’s dive straight into the differences.

  1. Fitbit Luxe and Charge 5 have a more colorful AMOLED display
  2. The first difference you will notice between these three is the color quality of the display. While the Vivosmart 5 has a monochrome OLED display, Charge 5 and Luxe have displays powered by AMOLED. As a result, these two have richer color depth and are satisfying to watch. Nonetheless, the monochrome OLED display of the Vivosmart 5 is very easy to read even under direct sunlight.

  3. Fitbit Charge 5 has a larger display
  4. Although each of these three has a tiny display which is normal for smartbands, the Charge 5 with a 1.04 inches display has a slightly larger display size than the 0.85 and 0.76 displays of Vivosmart 5 and Fitbit Luxe respectively.

    Meanwhile, while it’s very easy to interact with the Fitbit Charge 5 and Luxe which both offer touchscreen as the only means of navigation, the Vivosmart 5 offers both a touch-sensitive screen and a physical button. In other words, it’s quite easier to access.

  5. Fitbit Charge 5 and Luxe have better body build quality
  6. The Charge 5 and Luxe have better build quality. While the Charge 5 has an aluminum build, the Luxe has an even more durable stainless steel build. Meanwhile, the Vivosmart 5 has a case made of polycarbonate which no doubt is also very durable.

  7. Fitbit Charge 5 and Luxe have better screen quality
  8. Moreover, in addition to the more durable cases, the Charge 5 and Luxe have better and more durable Corning Gorilla Glass 3 screens. This is in contrast to the acrylic glass screen used for Vivosmart 5.

  9. Fitbit Charge 5 has NFC
  10. An NFC chip is built into the Charge 5, this enables Fitbit Pay (not available in every country) which will allow you to store your card details on the device so that you can make payments at select terminals.

    Meanwhile, the Luxe and Vivosmart 5 lack NFC chips and as a result, cannot be used to make payments.

  11. Fitbit Charge 5 has inbuilt GPS
  12. While the Vivosmart 5 and Luxe lack inbuilt GPS, there is an inbuilt GPS in the Charge 5. This will allow you to map your routes without carrying your phone along. Meanwhile, with Luxe and Vivosmart 5, you must carry your phone along to map your routes and track other outdoor metrics.

  13. Fitbit Charge 5 features ECG measurement
  14. While the Vivosmart 5 and Luxe lack ECG measurement, the Fitbit Charge 5 will allow you to take ECG measurements directly from the device. It joins Sense and Sense 2 which both feature ECG measurement.

  15. Vivosmart 5 features incidental fall detection
  16. With your phone nearby, the Vivosmart 5 can detect when a fall has occurred and will send a text with your location to a preset emergency contact. It will also start a call to this preset contact. This will allow you to get help as quickly as possible.

    The Vivosmart 5 also features the Garmin LiveTrack feature that will enable you to allow your friends to follow along as you workout outdoors. Spectators can see your location, pace and other metrics in real time.

    Meanwhile, Charge 5 and Luxe lack these safety features.

  17. Fitbit Charge 5 and Luxe can track skin temperature variations.
  18. Although the Charge 5 and Luxe lack a thermometer, they both leverage on existing sensors to track your skin temperature variation when you go to sleep. This is a great way to monitor your skin temperature changes. Meanwhile, the Vivosmart 5 can not track your skin temperature.

  19. Fitbit Charge 5 and Vivosmart 5 can monitor stress but not Luxe
  20. The Charge 5 and Vivosmart 5 are both equipped to monitor your stress levels 24/7, the Fitbit Luxe on the other hand can only help you reduce stress using the built-in breathing app but cannot monitor stress.

  21. Battery life: Charge 5 vs Vivosmart 5 vs Luxe
  22. Interestingly, all three smartbands have decent battery life that will allow you to go long from a single charge. With the Charge 5 and Vivosmart 5, you can get up to 7 days long battery life. And with Fitbit Luxe, it’s slightly lower, you get up to 5 days of battery life.

    In all, the Charge 5 and Luxe have better build quality than Vivosmart 5. Furthermore, the Charge 5 has more features. It features NFC, an inbuilt GPS, and more health-tracking features than Vivosmart 5 and Luxe.

    Charge 5 vs Vivosmart 5 vs Luxe – Similar Features

    Beyond the differences mentioned above, all three smartbands, are sturdily built and rated 5ATM. The straps are interchangeable and you can change watch faces.

    As per fitness tracking, each of these will track your blood oxygen, heart rate, calories burnt, steps and distance. Each of these three also has preloaded sports modes, and from their respective companion apps, you can track water intake and women can track their menstrual cycle.

    All three smartbands will also allow you to receive notifications when your phone is nearby. And you have the option to reply to messages using the quick replies function.

    Which is The Best?

    Clearly, the Charge 5 is better than Vivosmart 5. It has a better build, better display, inbuilt GPS, has NFC and features ECG and can monitor your skin temperature changes. It’s clearly a finer and more comprehensive tracker than Vivosmart 5. It’s clearly the best bargain.

    Meanwhile, the Vivosmart 5 is sturdily built and is also a fantastic fitness tracker. It features incidental fall detection and LiveTrack which no doubt makes it a better choice for outdoor workout activity lovers.

    On the other hand, Fitbit Luxe is simply adorable. Its stainless build makes it a pretty timepiece. And beyond the appearance, it’s also a comprehensive fitness tracker.

    Now the ball is in your court, make your choice!